WatchShop Wiki
Articles · The Swiss Watch StatuteWatchShop Wiki

Watch Statute · chapter 5

Protection or paralysis?

The case for the statute

Defenders of the watch statute argue that it saved the Swiss watch industry in the 1930s. Without it, they say, the industry would have collapsed in the Depression, and its know-how would have been dispersed abroad. The statute preserved jobs, maintained quality and protected the social fabric of the watch towns. Its success is shown by the industry’s strength in the postwar decades.

The case against

Critics argue that the statute froze the industry in an outdated structure. By protecting small firms from competition, it prevented the consolidation and modernization that would have made the industry more efficient. By restricting new entrants, it discouraged innovation. When the quartz challenge came, the industry was fragmented and slow to respond, while its Japanese competitors were large, integrated and technologically advanced.

A balanced view

Most historians take a balanced view. The statute was a reasonable response to a severe crisis, and it served the industry well for a time. But it outlived its usefulness and was dismantled too late. The industry’s problems in the 1970s had many causes, including the strength of the Swiss franc, the rapid pace of technological change and strategic mistakes by individual firms. The statute was one factor among many.

The Swiss Watch Statute · Debate5