WatchShop Wiki
Articles · Huygens, Hooke and the Balance SpringWatchShop Wiki · Vol. 2

Balance spring · chapter 2

Paris, London and a stolen secret

Huygens announces

In January 1675 Christiaan Huygens, then living in Paris as a leading member of the French Royal Academy of Sciences, designed a watch regulated by a flat spiral spring attached to the balance. He had the Parisian clockmaker Isaac Thuret build a prototype. Huygens wrote to Henry Oldenburg, the secretary of the Royal Society in London, announcing his invention in the form of an anagram, a common way for scientists of the period to establish priority without revealing details. A description followed in the Journal des Sçavans in February 1675.

Huygens also sought to protect his invention commercially. He obtained a privilege in France and explored the possibility of an English patent, again through Oldenburg.

Hooke objects

In London, the news provoked fury. Robert Hooke, the Royal Society’s curator of experiments and one of the most inventive scientists of the age, claimed that he had invented the spring-regulated balance years earlier. Hooke said he had been experimenting with springs applied to watch balances since around 1658 and had discussed the idea with members of the Society in the early 1660s. He had even been in negotiations to obtain a patent, which fell through, he said, because the backers wanted conditions he would not accept.

Hooke now accused Oldenburg of betraying him, suggesting that the secretary had passed his ideas to Huygens through their correspondence. The charge was never proved, and most historians doubt that Oldenburg acted dishonestly, but the quarrel poisoned relations inside the Royal Society for years.

The king’s watch

Hooke responded in the most practical way possible. He commissioned the London clockmaker Thomas Tompion, then a rising star, to build a watch with a spring of his design, and arranged for it to be presented to King Charles II. Accounts survive of a watch inscribed with the words that Robert Hooke had invented it in 1658 and Tompion had made it in 1675, a public statement of priority. The king was reportedly pleased, and Tompion’s reputation grew enormously.

A matter of shape

Part of the dispute concerned exactly what each man had invented. Hooke’s early springs seem to have been straight or only slightly curved, and they acted on the balance in a different way. Huygens’s design used a long spiral of several turns, which gave a much more even restoring force. The spiral form was the one that triumphed, and it remains the basis of the balance spring today. Many historians now credit Hooke with the general principle of using a spring to control a balance, and Huygens with the spiral form that made it practical. Both men were brilliant; both had reasons to feel wronged.

Hooke’s law

The quarrel had an unexpected scientific consequence. In 1676 Hooke published another anagram, which he revealed in 1678 as the Latin phrase ut tensio, sic vis: as the extension, so the force. This is Hooke’s law, the principle that the force exerted by a spring is proportional to how far it is stretched. It is exactly the property that makes a balance spring work, since a force proportional to displacement produces oscillations whose period does not depend on their size. Hooke had arrived at one of the fundamental laws of physics partly through thinking about watches.

Fame and bitterness

Huygens died in 1695, Hooke in 1703. Hooke spent his last years in a series of bitter arguments, most famously with Isaac Newton, who had little sympathy for him. For a long time Hooke’s reputation suffered, partly because no authenticated portrait of him survived and partly because Newton’s supporters dominated the Royal Society. Modern scholarship has restored much of his standing, and the balance-spring episode is now remembered as a case where two original minds were circling the same idea at the same time.

Huygens, Hooke and the Balance Spring · The quarrel12