Balance spring · chapter 4
Inside the heartbeat
Why does a spring make such a difference? A short explanation of the physics, and of the craftsmen who learned to master it.
The balance as a pendulum
Imagine a wheel free to turn on its axis, with a coiled spring attached between its hub and a fixed point on the watch frame. Twist the wheel and let go: the spring pulls it back past the center, it overshoots, the spring pulls it back again, and the wheel settles into a regular swinging motion. The time each swing takes depends on two things only, the stiffness of the spring and the mass and size of the wheel. It does not, ideally, depend on how far the wheel swings. That property, called isochronism, is what lets a watch keep steady time even as the mainspring runs down and the swings become smaller.
Hooke’s law is the reason. Because the spring pushes back with a force proportional to how far it has been twisted, a large swing is also driven back faster, and the larger distance and the higher speed cancel out. The mathematics was not fully understood in 1675, but the experimenters could see the effect on their workbenches.
Never quite perfect
In practice, no balance spring is perfectly isochronous. The way a spring is pinned at each end, the way it breathes as it coils and uncoils, the effect of gravity on a slightly unbalanced wheel and the changing stiffness of steel with temperature all spoil the ideal. For more than three hundred years, watchmakers have refined the shape of the spring to approach perfection. Abraham-Louis Breguet raised the outer end of the spring over the coils in a curve, the Breguet overcoil, so that it would breathe more evenly. Nineteenth-century scientists such as Édouard Phillips calculated the ideal curves for the terminal parts of the spring.
The material problem
A steel spring becomes weaker as it warms, which makes the watch lose time on a hot day. Early solutions used bimetallic balances that changed their size to compensate. The real answer came only in the twentieth century, when the Swiss-born physicist Charles-Édouard Guillaume, working in France, developed nickel-steel alloys whose elasticity hardly changes with temperature. His work on these alloys, including Invar and Elinvar, earned him the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1920. Later alloys such as Nivarox became the industry standard.
Thomas Tompion, the craftsman who benefited
Whatever the merits of the priority dispute, the craftsman who gained most from the balance spring was Thomas Tompion. Born in 1639 in Bedfordshire, the son of a blacksmith, he came to London as a young man and by the 1670s had a workshop in Fleet Street. Hooke’s commission made him famous at court. Over the following decades he produced around five and a half thousand watches and several hundred clocks, introduced serial numbers to keep track of his output and trained a generation of makers. In 1676 he built the two great clocks for the new Royal Observatory at Greenwich, which ran for a year on a single winding and helped the first Astronomer Royal, John Flamsteed, establish that the Earth rotates at a constant rate.
A small part with a large shadow
It is striking that one of the most important inventions in the history of timekeeping weighs only a few milligrams. The modern hairspring of a wristwatch is coiled from a ribbon of alloy that may be only a few hundredths of a millimeter thick. Making it remains one of the most specialized tasks in watchmaking, and for decades almost the entire Swiss industry relied on a single supplier for them. Control over the balance spring has always meant control over the watch.
A watch keeps time not because it is pushed, but because its spring always wants to return to rest.