Lever escapement · chapter 4
Challengers to the lever
One beat, step by step
It helps to follow a single beat. The balance swings, carrying a small jewel, the impulse pin, fixed to a disc on its staff. As the balance approaches the middle of its swing, the impulse pin enters the slot in the end of the lever, the fork, and nudges the lever sideways. This small movement lifts one pallet off the escape-wheel tooth it was locking. The train is released.
Now the escape wheel, driven by the mainspring, turns. Its tooth slides across the angled face of the pallet, pushing the lever onward, and the lever, through its fork, gives the impulse pin, and therefore the balance, a quick push. Almost at once the other pallet drops into the path of the next tooth and locks the wheel again. The lever is drawn against a banking pin and stays there. The balance, freshly energized, swings on alone, completes its arc, slows, stops, and is pulled back by its spring, ready to repeat the process from the other side.
All this happens in a few thousandths of a second, five, six or eight times every second. The balance spends perhaps ninety percent of its time completely free, which is exactly what Mudge set out to achieve. During the short moment of contact, the lever acts like a tiny relay, passing energy from the train to the balance while isolating the two from each other the rest of the time.
The importance of safety
A wristwatch is constantly shaken, knocked and turned. If the lever were free to wander while the balance was swinging, a sudden jolt could send it to the wrong side, where the impulse pin would strike it and stop the watch. Two features prevent this. The first is draw, the angling of the pallets so the escape wheel holds the lever firmly against its banking. The second is a guard pin, or dart, on the lever, which meets the edge of the balance roller if the lever tries to move at the wrong moment. These modest details, worked out over decades after Mudge, are a large part of why the lever made the transition from the pocket to the wrist so successfully.
Why look for something better?
For all its virtues, the lever escapement has a weakness: the pallets slide against the escape-wheel teeth as they deliver impulse, and sliding means friction. Friction needs oil, and oil ages, thickens and migrates. As the oil degrades, the performance of a lever escapement slowly declines, which is one of the main reasons mechanical watches need regular servicing.
George Daniels and the co-axial
The most famous attempt to improve on the lever came from the English watchmaker George Daniels, one of the very few people in modern times to make complete watches by hand. In the 1970s Daniels developed the co-axial escapement, which delivers impulse mainly by pushing rather than sliding, reducing friction. He spent years trying to interest the Swiss industry. Omega eventually adopted it, introducing the co-axial escapement in a series-produced watch in 1999, and has since made it standard in most of its mechanical movements.
Silicon and new materials
Since the early 2000s, several manufacturers have experimented with escape wheels and pallet forks made of silicon. Silicon is light, extremely hard, can be shaped with great precision and is not affected by magnetism. Its smooth surfaces need little or no oil. In this way, the lever has been given new life by twenty-first-century materials rather than replaced.
Other experiments
Watchmakers have proposed many other escapements, some revived from the eighteenth century and some new: the detent escapement of the marine chronometer adapted for wristwatches, constant-force escapements, and designs using flexible parts instead of pivots. A few have entered production in small numbers. None has yet displaced the lever in the vast majority of mechanical watches.
A remarkable survival
It is worth pausing on how unusual this is. Few mechanical inventions of the 1750s are still in daily use in essentially their original form. The lever escapement that Mudge built in Fleet Street has been refined, standardized, miniaturized and made in new materials, but its principle is unchanged. Every time you hear the tick of a mechanical watch, you are hearing the escape wheel locking against a pallet, as Mudge designed it two and a half centuries ago.