Dollar watch · chapter 3
The watch that made the dollar famous
Robert Ingersoll was a salesman, not a watchmaker. His genius lay in seeing that a watch could be sold like any other everyday product.
The mail-order brothers
Robert Hawley Ingersoll was born in 1859 in Michigan. In 1882 he moved to New York and started a mail-order business selling rubber stamps and other small items at low prices. His brother Charles joined him, and the business, Robert H. Ingersoll and Brother, expanded into a range of cheap novelties sold through catalogs.
In the early 1890s, the brothers began selling watches. At first they bought inexpensive watches from manufacturers and sold them by mail. Then, in 1892, they made a deal with the Waterbury Clock Company of Connecticut to supply them with a very cheap pocket watch. The price, at first, was a little more than one dollar. By 1896, the Ingersoll brothers were selling a watch called the Yankee for exactly one dollar.
Clock-factory methods
The Waterbury Clock Company was well placed to make such a watch. It had experience producing inexpensive clocks in vast numbers, using stamped brass parts and simple mechanisms. The Yankee was made in the same way. It had a stamped brass movement, a pin-lever escapement, no jewels and a plain case of nickel-plated brass. It was not finely made, and it was not designed to be repaired, but it kept reasonable time and was surprisingly durable.
A slogan for the age
The Ingersoll brothers were brilliant marketers. They advertised widely and sold the watches through general stores, drugstores, tobacconists and mail-order catalogs, rather than only through jewelers. The slogan they adopted, the watch that made the dollar famous, became one of the best-known advertising lines in America. The dollar watch became a symbol of the modern consumer economy: a product of mass production, sold through mass distribution, at a price anyone could afford.
Ingersoll sold millions of watches. By the early twentieth century, the company claimed that it was producing thousands of watches a day, and its total sales eventually ran into the tens of millions. It expanded into Britain, where Ingersoll Ltd became a well-known brand, and offered a range of models, including small watches for women and children and later wristwatches.
The Waterbury watch
Before the Ingersoll deal, Connecticut had already tried to make a very cheap watch. In 1880, the Waterbury Watch Company, linked to the Benedict and Burnham brass firm, began producing a watch designed by the inventor Daniel Azro Ashley Buck. It had a rotating movement and an extraordinarily long mainspring, more than two meters of steel, which needed well over a hundred turns of the crown to wind fully. The watch sold for a few dollars and was given away as a premium with clothing and newspapers. It sold in large numbers, but the endless winding became a joke, and its reputation suffered. The lesson was not lost on later makers: a cheap watch had to be convenient as well as inexpensive.
How a cheap watch was built
The Yankee and its successors were designed around the punch press. Plates, wheels and many other parts were stamped from sheet brass in a single stroke, rather than cut and turned. Pinions were made from steel wire, and pivots ran directly in holes in the brass plates. Assembly was organized like a production line, with each worker performing a single operation. Quality control was statistical rather than individual: a certain percentage of watches was tested, not every one. The result was a product whose cost was a small fraction of a jeweled watch, and whose reliability was good enough for most people.
Customers and critics
Jewelers and established watchmakers looked down on dollar watches, which they could not repair profitably and which threatened their trade in cheaper jeweled watches. Critics complained that the watches were disposable and inaccurate. But customers loved them. A dollar watch could be carried into a coal mine, a cornfield or a factory floor without worry. If it was lost or broken, it could be replaced for the price of a meal and a few drinks. For many of its owners, it was the first manufactured precision product they had ever bought.
Trouble and takeover
The dollar price was difficult to maintain. Inflation during the First World War pushed up costs, and the company was forced to raise prices. After the war, competition increased, and the company ran into financial difficulties. In 1922 Ingersoll went bankrupt, and its American business was bought by the Waterbury Clock Company, its longtime supplier. The British Ingersoll business continued separately for many years.
Who could now tell the time
The significance of the dollar watch lies in who used it. Farmers, factory workers, schoolchildren, soldiers and immigrants, people who had never owned a watch before, could now carry one. Contemporary accounts describe workers proudly checking their dollar watches against the factory whistle. Personal time, once a privilege of the few, became a part of everyday life for millions.
The dollar watch did not keep perfect time. It did something more important: it gave time to people who had never owned it.
From the proletarian watch to Timex
- 1867Roskopf
A simple pin-lever watch for working people.
- 1880Waterbury
Connecticut’s clockmakers start making cheap watches.
- 1896Yankee
Ingersoll sells a watch for one dollar.
- 1922Bankruptcy
Waterbury Clock buys Ingersoll’s American business.
- 1933Mickey Mouse
A character watch rescues the company in the Depression.
- 1950Timex
The successor company launches the Timex name.